Haiti - Justice : CSPJ/CEP, complications in perspective - HaitiLibre.com : Haiti news 7/7





iciHaiti - National Diaspora Day : Message from the Minister of MHAVE

iciHaiti - PNCS : Monitoring and evaluation tour of school canteens

iciHaiti - FLASH : Cuba launches an evacuation operation for its citizens stranded in Haiti

iciHaiti - Montreal, Cinema Festival : The Haitian documentary «1964 : Simityè kamoken» in the spotlight

iciHaiti - NOTICE Diaspora : Delay in the delivery of Haitian passports in Spain


more news


Haiti - News : Zapping...

Haiti - National Diaspora Day : Message of reflection from Lesly Condé

Haiti - Football : Concacaf reveals all the details of the Natons League

Haiti - FLASH : Nearly 28 Haitians killed or injured every day, increase of 53% in the 1st quarter

Haiti - News : Zapping...


more news


Haiti - Justice : CSPJ/CEP, complications in perspective
09/10/2012 10:54:24

Haiti - Justice : CSPJ/CEP, complications in perspective
Monday, during a press conference Salnave Exantus and Yves Benoît Jean-Marie, two of the three representatives of the Supreme Council of the Judiciary (CSPJ) installed in the Permanent Electoral Council, have expressed publicly for the first time. Yves Benoît Jean Marie, one of the representatives of the CSPJ speaking on behalf of these two colleagues declared "we never go in the press, but however, at this stage of the discussion we believe that [...] to preserve our honesty and our entirety of the work done in 40 years of life, we believe it is appropriate to fix our position.

I said personally and on behalf of my colleagues, I have sworn by the Court of Cassation [...] after the publication of a presidential decree, who appointed me from the choice made by the CSPJ. Based on this principle, it is necessary that we are unanimous to recognize together with me, that it is true that I have been chosen by the CSPJ. Now, I want to remind the public [...] that the Electoral Council is an autonomous and independent institution and therefore I am immovable [...]"


Advisers recalled that only the High Court of Justice could dismiss them, if they have committed any crime. "If we make serious mistakes in our work, we are ready to respond to these faults before the High Court of Justice."

From his part, on Tuesday, the CSPJ is preparing to proceed to the appointment of 3 new representatives. According to Me Néhémy Joseph, spokesman of the CSPJ, the 3 representatives of the Judiciary installed to the CEP, not consider themselves as candidates, but as already elected representatives have refused to come to the invitation of Council as part of process of investigating on the 12 candidates. Consequently, their names do not appear on the list, now reduced to 9 candidates...

On the other side, information suggests that 6 out of the 9 remaining candidates were not retained in the process of vetting. What will happen if the CSPJ appoints 3 new representatives ? What status they will have, given the existence of 3 representatives already elected to the CEP, who have no intention of resigning ?

Moreover, the problem of the legitimacy of Me Anel Alexis Joseph [72], President of CSPJ and the Court of Cassation, whose appointment does not meet the age limit set at 65, remains unsolved. In this regard, Me Carlos Hercules, member of CSPJ and President of the Bars Federation of Haiti (FBH) had declared "[...] There is the article 51 which speaks of an age limit for that name appears on a list that is 65 while the current President has over 70 years [...] there is a flaw [...] But this remains a political decision because it is necessary that we say, nobody has the authority to decide today the removal of a judge of the Court of Cassation in office, except the High Court of Justice [...] If the impeachment proceedings is not made before the High Court of Justice, there is only a compromise, as if he asserted his right to retire, since it has the retirement age [...] I think it would be a really happy exit for the President of the Court of Cassation [...]"

A situation likely to be more complicated, with the probable designation today of 3 new representative of the CSPJ. If several parliamentarians did not hesitate to point the finger at the Head of the State as holder of the solution, it is illusory to believe in a intervention of President Martelly in this business, if we refer to the last position the weekend at Club Indigo before 8 Senators where he reaffirmed his conviction to never interfere in the internal affairs of the Judiciary in strict compliance with the Constitution, of laws on separation of the three powers.

See also :
https://www.haitilibre.com/en/news-6801-haiti-justice-second-postponement-of-vote-at-cspj.html
https://www.haitilibre.com/en/news-6732-haiti-politic-the-cspj-and-the-executive-have-no-power-on-the-advisers-of-cep.html
https://www.haitilibre.com/en/news-6720-haiti-justice-me-carlos-hercules-wonders-about-the-withdrawal-of-representatives-of-the-cspj.html
https://www.haitilibre.com/en/news-6705-haiti-justice-the-president-of-the-cspj-gave-way-under-the-pressure.html

HL/ S/ HaitiLibre

Twitter Facebook Rss
Send news to... Daily news...




Why HaitiLibre ? | Contact us | Français
Copyright © 2010 - 2024
Haitilibre.com